Maybe I just came to it too late. Until last night I had never seen a famous film that shaped the psyche of my generation. Until last night, I had never seen a modern classic. Until last night, I had never seen The Breakfast Club.
Until last night, I always thought I’d like it.
If I’d seen it first at 14, not at 38, I’m sure my response would have been different. At 14, I would have empathized with the characters, would have felt their plight as they struggled against the arbitrary cruelty of public education. I would have related to their efforts to define themselves outside the simple definitions placed on them by the artificial school system.
At 38, I was just bored. And a little unsettled. I had gone in expecting the kind of warmth that has endeared to me other John Hughes films. I was expecting a little “Home Alone” and instead got something closer to “Home for the Insane.”
The characters’ harsh language and treatment of one another drained the film of its humor and me of my empathy. I found it difficult to feel sorry for any of them, especially John Bender, the group’s criminal ringleader.
The lack of clear resolution didn’t help. When the final credits began to roll, I was still unsure of what had happened, still unclear what, if anything, had changed for these people.
I was too young ,just 14 or 15, to see The Breakfast Club in its original run. The John Hughes film that defined adolescence for me came a few years later and stands, I think, as his masterpiece. No movie until that time affected me Like Ferris Bueller’s Day Off. Oh, how I wanted to be Ferris.
Both John Bender and Ferris invite others to confront the truth about themselves, but Ferris accomplishes this through play rather than through the kind of verbal violence that characterizes Bender. Ferris Bueller and The Breakfast Club hit on the same theme: that public school is a stupid waste of time. But, the warmth of Ferris Bueller makes that message so much easier to digest. So, Bueller is a movie I will return to, but now I know I have no desire ever to be again a member of The Breakfast Club.
Save Ferris!
Somewhere early on, probably in my ninth or tenth year, I discovered I could call myself on the telephone. I have been fascinated by telephones since I was a kid. The notion of an anonymous, disembodied voice whispering in my ear has long held me frozen in creepy thrall. Even today, I sometimes spend time reading online about phones and their lore.
We came for the free rentals. We stayed for the memories.